10 Best Puppy Teething Toys 2025 in the United States

The Benebone Puppy Holiday 4-Pack Dog Chew Toys is a well-thought-out option for puppy owners looking for effective teething solutions. This pack includes four different chew toys, making it a great value and ideal for puppies of all sizes (30lbs and under). One of its standout features is the use of real bacon flavoring in three of the toys, which dogs find irresistible, helping to keep them engaged and satisfied during the teething phase.

In terms of material, these toys are made from durable nylon and a softer thermoplastic rubber (TPE) for the smaller Zaggler, which caters perfectly to modest chewers. This flexibility in material choice can be a double-edged sword; while the softer Zaggler is safer for tiny pups, the durability of the nylon may not be sufficient for more aggressive chewers. Therefore, if you have an enthusiastic chewer, you may want to monitor usage closely.

The size and shape of these toys are thoughtfully designed. They are easy for puppies to grip and chew, ensuring that your furry friend can enjoy them without frustration. However, some pet parents have reported that the 6.5 x 5.75 x 3-inch dimensions may be a bit large for very small breeds, which could affect their ability to play comfortably. Safety is a key consideration, and these toys are made in the USA, meaning they adhere to stricter manufacturing standards. The brand also emphasizes customer service, offering a satisfaction guarantee, which is always reassuring for puppy owners.

The KONG Puppy Natural Teething Rubber Chew Toy is specifically designed for small puppies, making it a great option in the puppy-teething-toys category. One of its standout features is the customized natural rubber material that is soft enough for a puppy's delicate teeth yet durable enough to withstand plenty of chewing. This ensures that the toy is gentle on their gums while helping to relieve teething discomfort, a key requirement for new puppy parents.

The toy's size is appropriate for small breeds, which enhances its effectiveness during playtime. It also provides a fun bounce, encouraging interactive games like fetch, which can be great for bonding and exercise. Additionally, the ability to stuff the toy with treats or food is a big plus, as it not only keeps puppies engaged but can also aid in crate training, making it a versatile choice for pet owners.

The KONG Puppy Chew Toy is a solid choice for small puppies, offering comfort, engagement, and some training benefits. Just keep an eye on it during play to ensure it remains safe and intact.

The Petstages Cool Teething Stick is an excellent option for teething puppies. Made from a soft cotton-polyester fabric, it is designed to be gentle on your puppy's sore gums. Its unique feature is that it can be soaked in water and frozen, providing a soothing coolness that can help relieve teething discomfort. This toy is also a great way to divert your puppy's chewing urges from your furniture to a more appropriate object, which can reduce destructive behavior.

The toy is colorful and available in a one-size-fits-all design, making it suitable for puppies of all breeds and sizes. Although the toy is durable, it's essential to supervise your pet while they use it and replace it if it becomes damaged, as no toy is indestructible. This teething stick is particularly beneficial for active, indoor use and offers both fun and practical benefits for your pup.